• Question: Does your heart have memories or feelings?

    Asked by wizzyg12 to Rob, Matt, Kate, Claire on 25 Jun 2013.
    • Photo: Robert Woolfson

      Robert Woolfson answered on 25 Jun 2013:


      Scientifically speaking, yes. The heart is a muscle that beats to send blood around your body at a certain speed. The heart has memory in the sense it has DNA which is a form of memory that stores information about a person.

      On a more personal note, I believe that the memories and feelings that make us human reside in the brain. Other people feel differently. There’s a poem on the GCSE English course I remember studying called Homecoming. I remember it because it sparked a very strong debate about exactly this topic in my class. I’ve attached the words below (courtesy of http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/english_literature/poetarmitage/ivemadeoutawillrev1.shtml)

      I’ve made out a will; I’m leaving myself
      to the National Health. I’m sure they can use
      the jellies and tubes and syrups and glues,
      the web of nerves and veins, the loaf of brains,
      and assortment of fillings and stitches and wounds,
      blood – a gallon exactly of bilberry soup –
      the chassis or cage or cathedral of bone;
      but not the heart, they can leave that alone.
      They can have the lot, the whole stock:
      the loops and coils and sprockets and springs and rods,
      the twines and cords and strands,
      the face, the case, the cogs and the hands,
      but not the pendulum, the ticker;
      leave that where it stops or hangs.

    • Photo: Claire Lee

      Claire Lee answered on 26 Jun 2013:


      Cool poem Rob!

      Yeah, I don’t think that the heart, as a muscle, has memories or feelings as we define them. Those are chemical reactions that happen in the brain. But who knows – maybe a cardiac surgeon would disagree 🙂

    • Photo: Matthew Pankhurst

      Matthew Pankhurst answered on 26 Jun 2013:


      That’s a really cool answer Rob! I didn’t think of a each cell having “memory”, but really they all do in a sense! The only thing I would add that is that sometimes our heart feels like it has feelings because if we feel something strongly often our heart will beat a little faster, like if we are nervous or really excited…. or in love….! So we have that physical feeling, which makes it seem like that is where the feeling is coming from, even though it is actually happening in our brains.

Comments